Prudential Douglas Elliman logo
 SERVING ALL FIRE ISLAND
    631.597.3030 - 631.597.3125
   
HOME   |   ABOUT US   |   OUR AGENTS   |   MY DREAM HOME   |   PROFILE   |   HOW WE HELP YOU   |   CONTACT US
Properties for Rent |   VIEW PROPERTIES FOR SALE »
   CHERRY GROVE      DAVIS PARK    |    FIRE ISLAND PINES    |    OCEAN BAY PARK    |    SEAVIEW    |    WATER ISLAND
   Seasonal Rentals   |   Monthly Rentals   |   Weekly Rentals  
      
   V I E W   B Y   P R I C E   R A N G E »    |    V I E W   B Y   N U M B E R   O F   B E D R O O M S »                                    RETURN TO TOP »
   
70,000 to 35,000 »   |   35,000 to 25,000 »   |   25,000 to 20,000 »   |   20,000 to 15,000 »   |   15,000 to 10,000 »   |   10,000 to 7,000 »
  
OFFERED AT $70,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Magnificent residence, second from the beach. 5 Bedroom, 4.5 Bathroom, loft style living and dining room and a full circular island gourmet kitchen. All living areas open out to wrap around multilevel decks, and full roof deck.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $50,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 5 Bedroom, 2 full Bathroom, grand LR equipped with wood burning fireplace, wrap around windows and French doors, den, and a cozy sunroom overlooking the Great South Bay. Manicured grounds.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $45,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 4.5 Bedroom, 3 Bathroom, Large Bayfront home, decks and balcony overlooking Bay and gardens. Greatroom/Kitchen on first floor, Living-room on second floor with vaulted ceilings.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $45,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom residence in the central Grove, fully equipped with high end appliances and finishes (including double-room fireplace) central air, vaulted ceilings, outdoor decks, Pool.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
OFFERED AT $38,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom with enormous decks on two floors. The open plan includes a large fully equipped kitchen and living area that opens onto the first floor deck. Large bright bedrooms, master bedroom opens onto a spacious deck.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
      
   V I E W   B Y   P R I C E   R A N G E »    |    V I E W   B Y   N U M B E R   O F   B E D R O O M S »                                    RETURN TO TOP »
   
70,000 to 35,000 »   |   35,000 to 25,000 »   |   25,000 to 20,000 »   |   20,000 to 15,000 »   |   15,000 to 10,000 »   |   10,000 to 7,000 »
  
OFFERED AT $33,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom bayfront home, in the east end of Cherry Grove. Fully equipped kitchen, flowing out to great room style living/dining, with wall to wall glass overlooking the Great South Bay.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $30,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 story home feels like a 200-year old Venetian Palace… an oversized high-style living room with a wood burning fireplace, full gourmet kitchen, formal dining room, 2 full baths. The second level consists of 3 extra-large bedrooms.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $28,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Inviting 1500 Sf Summer Residence, 3 Bedroom, Full Bath, Grand Living Room With Wood Burning Fireplace And Wrap Around Windows, Sunroom Overlooking The Great South Bay.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
OFFERED AT $28,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Traditional home on the Grove West End. Newly remodeled, 3 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom home with great light & volume, approx 150 ft. to the beach. Large living and dining areas, fireplace, and exceptional outdoor spaces.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
      
   V I E W   B Y   P R I C E   R A N G E »    |    V I E W   B Y   N U M B E R   O F   B E D R O O M S »                                    RETURN TO TOP »
   
70,000 to 35,000 »   |   35,000 to 25,000 »   |   25,000 to 20,000 »   |   20,000 to 15,000 »   |   15,000 to 10,000 »   |   10,000 to 7,000 »
  
OFFERED AT $25,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom bungalow, recently renovated, situated on a large property - an incredible gem next to the national seashore parklands. Open floor plan living - living/ dining/kitchen great room, with glass surrounds. Incredible light.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $25,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 bedroom with lots of light and windows on three sides. The bedrooms each have sliding glass doors to their own decks. Well equipped kitchen. Laundry facilities and each bedroom has a private entry.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $25,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, outfitted with a large pool, hot tub, grill, outdoor shower, wood burning stove and privacy fence to make this home your dream oasis in Paradise. Roof terrace. A true vacationers dream.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $25,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. New England style summer residence - waterfront on the Great South Bay. 2 Bedroom, full bath, grand living room and wrap around windows and french doors leading to open deck areas on the bay.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $24,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 3 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom. Large Graceful Beach House rental, located in the Grove's east end. Large, bright, with great volume spaces, recent renovation, superb kitchen with concrete counter tops, large and privacy fenced decks.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $24,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Beautiful summer cottage. 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home, with large open living areas, full kitchen, and outdoor decks and gardens, including an outdoor shower.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $22,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, Large and Beautiful Summer Residence. Remodeled Property Offers Magnificent Volume Space, Inside And Out. Open Great Room With South & East Exposures, And Hi-Style Kitchen, Large Deck.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $22,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom,1 bathroom, with beautiful outdoor space, gardens. Large open floorplan living, dining kitchen, large master bedroom, tastefully decorated with period furnishings, washer and dryer.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $22,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, with pool and bay views - large great room living/dining/kitchen, bath, and spacious bedrooms. Excellent outdoor deck overlooking the bay, and large pool. Washer/dryer.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $22,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, East End Of Cherry Grove, Decks, Great Room Style Living/Dining Area, And Full Kitchen, All With Views Of The Great South Bay.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
OFFERED AT $21,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 3/4 SHARE - 2 bedroom with lots of light and windows on three sides. The bedrooms each have sliding glass doors to their own decks. Well equipped kitchen. Laundry facilities and each bedroom has a private entry.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
      
   V I E W   B Y   P R I C E   R A N G E »    |    V I E W   B Y   N U M B E R   O F   B E D R O O M S »                                    RETURN TO TOP »
   
70,000 to 35,000 »   |   35,000 to 25,000 »   |   25,000 to 20,000 »   |   20,000 to 15,000 »   |   15,000 to 10,000 »   |   10,000 to 7,000 »
  
OFFERED AT $18,750 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1 Bedroom, Bathed In Natural Sunlight And Offer Spectacular Views Through 9-Foot Wide Glass Patio Doors And Private Bay-Front Deck, Recently Renovated. En-Suite, Air-Conditioned & High-Speed Internet.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $18,750 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. One-of-a-kind renovation, best views. 1 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, AC. Great room style LR/DR/kitchen with high end appliances. Modern design ammenities, water side deck for best bay and sunset views.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $18,750 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1 Bedroom, great Sunlight And Spectacular Views Wide Glass Doors, Bayfront Deck, Recently Renovated. A/C, Sat TV/DVD and Wireless Internet Access!
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $18,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom seasonal summer rental. Nicely remodeled, great outdoor space, views from almost every room. Excellent location.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $18,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, duplex rental, beautifully appointed, full kitchen with stainless appliances, lots of light, great outdoor spaces, a/c, w/d, and outdoor shower. No pets, no smoking indoors.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $17,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Oceanfront 1 Bedroom, 2 Baths residence in the central Grove. Newly constructed beachfront home, fully equipped with high end appliances and finishes with fireplace, central air, outdoor decks, great natural light.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $17,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Traditional 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom beach residence. Tastefully renovated to maintain the charm in which the house was designed for originally, has a grand balcony, and manicured gardens.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $16,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Traditional beach Grove Cottage, 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom rental with own access to beach. Large, beach-cabin style, lots of light and ocean breeze. No pets.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $16,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom beach residence, located in the Grove’s east-end, very bright and airy, excellent detail. Fully outfitted, just bring your beach gear.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $16,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1 Bedroom. Spacious sunny apartment, with fully outfitted kitchen, outdoor decks with a BBQ grill (on both the ocean and walk sides of the house) for quiet enjoyment. Satellite TV/VCR included. 1 pet allowed.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $16,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1 Bedroom. Spacious sunny apartment, with fully outfitted kitchen, outdoor decks with a BBQ grill (on both the ocean and walk sides of the house) for quiet enjoyment. Satellite TV/VCR included. 1 pet allowed.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
OFFERED AT $16,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large relaxed beach cottage styled 3 bedroom 1 bathroom rental, charming old Grove property, excellent large outdoor deck with privacy-fencing. Open floor plan living/dining, large bedrooms, bright & cheerful. Approx. 200 ft. to the beach.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
      
   V I E W   B Y   P R I C E   R A N G E »    |    V I E W   B Y   N U M B E R   O F   B E D R O O M S »                                    RETURN TO TOP »
   
70,000 to 35,000 »   |   35,000 to 25,000 »   |   25,000 to 20,000 »   |   20,000 to 15,000 »   |   15,000 to 10,000 »   |   10,000 to 7,000 »
  
OFFERED AT $15,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1/2 SHARE - 2 bedroom with lots of light and windows on three sides. The bedrooms each have sliding glass doors to their own decks. Well equipped kitchen. Laundry facilities and each bedroom has a private entry.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $15,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom, recently remodeled inside and out. Located in the West end of Cherry Grove. Excellent light, and air, private furnished outdoor deck. Great location approx. 100 ft. to the beach.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $14,900 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large bright 2 Bedroom, east end of Cherry Grove. TV with satellite service. Privacy-fenced outdoor deck spaces. Approx 200 ft. to town center or beach.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $14,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1 Bedroom Cottage with fabulous water and sunset views. Large waterfront bayfront cottage, approx. 250 ft. to the beach and heart of village. Fully furnished and accessorized. Spectacular sunset views.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $14,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large yet quaint beach cottage - 1 Bedroom 1 Bath, full kitchen, plenty of outdoor space surrounding this really old world Grove cottage. Approx. 100 ft to the beach on the Grove's east end.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $13,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. STUDIO -Oceanside deck, and own access to the beach. Designed for easy living, this comfortable and cheerful studio is ideal for your summer getaway on the ocean. Fully equipped kitchen, TV/VCR, satellite. 1 pet acceptable.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $13,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1 Bedroom. Large bright and airy. Large outdoor space. Located in the Grove's East-End with a large open floorplan - very well appointed. Outdoor deck is privacy fenced. No pets.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $12,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. STUDIO - Charming waterfront studio rental. Excellent space, high end appliances, a/c, satellite TV, Washer/dryer access, and outdoor shower. Privacy-fenced outdoor space makes this studio even larger.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $12,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Charming 1 Bedroom rental with large open floorplan living dining area, full kitchen, and separate sunroom/den. Excellent outdoor space, surrounded with mature trees, and greenery. Privacy fenced yard. Washer/dryer.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
OFFERED AT $11,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. En-Suite, A/C And Ceiling Fans, High-Speed Wireless Internet And Satellite Tv (Hbo, Cinemax, Starz Etc.). Effiency Kitchen With Refrigerator And Mini Appliances. Onsite Laundry Facility.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
      
   V I E W   B Y   P R I C E   R A N G E »    |    V I E W   B Y   N U M B E R   O F   B E D R O O M S »                                    RETURN TO TOP »
   
70,000 to 35,000 »   |   35,000 to 25,000 »   |   25,000 to 20,000 »   |   20,000 to 15,000 »   |   15,000 to 10,000 »   |   10,000 to 7,000 »
  
OFFERED AT $10,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large relaxed beach cottage style 1 Bedroom, 1 Bath rental, charming old Grove property, excellent large outdoor deck. Open floor plan living/dining, large bedroom, bright & cheerful. Approx. 200 ft. to the beach.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $10,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE.

RENTED
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $9,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Beautiful guesthouse/studio rental, located int the Grove's east end. Large, bright, with central air, and privacy fenced decks. This summer homes is located approx. 300 feet to the beach! Excellent space, inside and out!
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $9,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large Studio approx 350 ft to town and apprx. 250 ft to the beach. Great space inside, but even more outdoor space. Beautiful summer home.

SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $9,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Studio apartment close to center of town and beach.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $8,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large studio with full bath, and privacy-fenced outdoor deck space. Approx. 200 ft to town center or beach. Located in the east end of Cherry Grove.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $8,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Large studio with full bath, and privacy-fenced outdoor deck space. Approx. 200 ft to town center or beach. Located in the east end of Cherry Grove.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $8,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Studio rental, beautifully appointed, efficiency kitchen, comfortable living area, lots of light, great outdoor spaces, a/c, w/d, and outdoor shower. No pets, no smoking indoors.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $7,800 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. 1/4 SHARE - 2 bedroom with lots of light and windows on three sides. The bedrooms each have sliding glass doors to their own decks. Well equipped kitchen. Laundry facilities and each bedroom has a private entry.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
Cherry Grove Fire Island Real Estate; 2 Bedroom Apartment; B-Share; $7,500. http://www.cjmingolelli.com
OFFERED AT $7,500 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. B-SHARE - New & beautifully remodeled, 2 Bedroom 2 Bathroom apartment. Master en-suite bedroom. Immaculate, bright, spacious, well maintained and fully outfitted. Shared common roof deck,water views.
SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
  
OFFERED AT $7,000 per season »
CHERRY GROVE. Beautifully Maintained Studio Apartment On 2nd Floor Of Oceanside Complex, Approx 100' To Beach Or Town Center. Beautiful views from common roof deck, Bay and Ocean

SEE FULL LISTING »      |     SEND US AN EMAIL »
    
RETURN TO TOP >
   
HOME   |   ABOUT US   |   OUR AGENTS   |   MY DREAM HOME   |   PROFILE   |   HOW WE HELP YOU   |   CONTACT US
         
 
631.597.3030
Douglas Elliman
Real Estate

Corner of Bay and Ocean Walks
Cherry Grove, NY 11782
 
212.321.7117
Douglas Elliman
Real Estate

26 West 17th Street
New York, NY 10011
      
www.elliman.com/fireisland         www.thebestoffireisland.com
                  

                          All data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the RLS or Douglas Elliman. See Term of ServiceTerms of Service for additional
                          restrictions.

                          All information regarding a property for sale, rental, taxes or financing is from sources deemed reliable. No representation is made as to the
                          accuracy thereof, and such information is subject to errors, omission, change of price, rental, commission, prior sale, lease or financing, or
                          withdrawal without notice. All square footage and dimensions are approximate. Exact dimensions can be obtained by retaining the services of
                          a professional architect or engineer. The number of bedrooms listed above is not a legal conclusion. Each person should consult with his/her
                          own attorney, architect or zoning expert to make a determination as to the number of rooms in the unit that may be legally used as a bedroom.

                          © 2013. Douglas Elliman Real Estate. All material presented herein is intended for information purposes only. While this information is believed
                          to be correct, it is represented subject to errors, omissions, changes or withdrawal without notice. All property information, including, but not
                          limited to square footage, room count, number of bedrooms and the school district in property listings are deemed reliable, but should be verify
                          by your own attorney, architect or zoning expert.
 Equal Housing Opportunity.